Register

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.


A password will be e-mailed to you.

Fantastic Four #1

Written by James Robinson

Pencils by Leonard Kirk

Inks by Karl Kesel

Colors by Jesus Aburtov

Review by Bobby Shortle

It has been a year of upheaval for The Fantastic Four. Writer Jonathan Hickman wrapped up his epic 5 year run, Matt Fraction, who started with so much promise, came and left the book before he could even get started, and Tom Breevort ended his record setting run as editor on the title. These departures threatened to leave the first family of Marvel in a state of flux.  But, uncertainty isn’t the way of big companies, so thanks to All-New Marvel Now, Leonard Kirk and recent DC expatriate James Robinson, we now have Fantastic Four #1 in our hands.  fantastic-four-alex-ross

Writer James Robinson nails the tone of what a Fantastic Four book should be. From page one you can feel that this is a close knit family with a deep and rich past. Robinson also shines in the dark, foreboding and yet somehow also delicate narration he gives to Sue Storm. This voice over sets her up as the spine of the book, and taken on its own, it’s a perfect way to set up a number one issue.  There is also a moment when the children from the Future Foundation enter the fray, I won’t spoil it, but lets just say it involves a “Death by Chocolate Ray” , that is absolute magic.

Unfortunately, these special moments are interrupted by the book’s one overriding fault, its dialogue.  Every moment the characters should hold their tongues and let the art speak for itself, Robinson continually forces awkward phrasings and on the nose sentiments into their mouths. It weighs down the narrative and makes otherwise touching scenes fall flat.  The low point of the book sees Reed asking how Sue is doing because “She looked sad standing over there” It’s a completely unnecessary line because I can see the deep pain on her face thanks to the gorgeous art.

If there is one takeaway from this #1, it has to be the simply stunning work of Leonard Kirk. I’ve enjoyed Mr. Kirk’s work in the past, but to me the pages in Fantastic Four #1 are on an entirely different level.  His rendering of the team, from Ben Grim’s craggy exterior, to Johnny’s fiery visage, is a painterly marvel. He also manages to portray the range of human emotions and the electricity of battle with equal flair. (His take on Fin Fang Foom had my jaw on the floor.) The art is so good that I’m inspired to pick up a second issue on its merits alone.

VERDICT:

Wait and See – James Robison succeeds in capturing the spirit of Reed, Sue, Ben and Johnny, but fails with the on the nose dialogue he uses to bring them to life. Fantastic Four #1 is redeemed though by the gorgeous art of Leonard Kirk.  There is promise, but until that is fulfilled its safe to wait this one out.

2 Responses

  1. thisjohnd

    Great review as always, Bobby. I too had problems with this issue, though mine were more so plot-related than dialogue-related. I know this has become a staple of James Robinson, but I felt like by setting up big changes in the opening pages that would not come to fruition until much later in the arc, the issue can’t really stand on its own. Robinson’s obviously catering toward a larger story which I’m sure will read better together than it does in single issue form. Unfortunately it means each issue every month will be incomplete, and although I’ve been collecting each F4 issue since Civil War, I might have to start trade waiting.

    • Bobby Shortle

      That’s a good point. Although I’ve come to not expect the major monthly Marvel books to have issues that can stand on their own. If you look at the likes of The Avengers, Superior Spider-Man and the X-Men titles they, with a few exceptions, tend to have issues that feel more like acts than full stories. I’m not saying this is right its just changed my expectations of what these books will be. I’m rooting for the title, but I get concerned when a #1 doesn’t grab me.

Leave a Reply